How to Review a Losing Trade
Every loss is game film… and George shows you exactly how to run the tape back.
2022–2026
Reviewing a losing trade means turning the loss into information. You screenshot the trade the moment it stops out, upload it to your journal, and ask one question… what is this loss telling you? Were you trading outside your hours? Outside your system? Should you have been in at all? Every stop hands you a data point about your process. The trader who reviews it grows. The trader who buries it repeats it.
“Stops provide information. What is it telling you? That’s what we’re going to talk about today. Should I be trading? That’s always a question to ask. Were you trading outside of your system? Should you have been trading at all?”
This page gathers everything George teaches about reviewing losing trades across hundreds of hours of live ES E-mini futures and MES micro futures sessions… why a loss is game film, the exact steps to take in the fifteen minutes after it happens, and how to mine your own trade history for the patterns that quietly cost you money.
A Loss Is Information, Not a Verdict
Start here, because it changes everything downstream. A stop-loss is feedback. Taking the loss gives you something the winning trade never will… a clear look at where your read, your timing, or your discipline broke down. Ask the question every time. Were you on the wrong side of price action? Were you trading your plan or trading your feelings?
“Stops provide you information. What is it telling you? Are you on the wrong side of price action?”
George reframes the whole idea of a bad day. The trades that hurt are the ones that teach. That painful stop drilled risk management into you. That failed FOMO entry sharpened your patience for the next setup. Reviewed honestly, your ugliest sessions do more for your account than your smoothest ones.
“Your worst trading days are actually your best training days.”
None of that works if the loss just stings and disappears. You have to capture it while it’s fresh. That’s the difference between paying tuition and actually enrolling in the lesson. If you want the mindset foundation behind this, pair it with Be a Professional Loser.
Screenshot the Loss the Moment It Happens
The review starts before the emotion fades. Take the loss, then take the screenshot. Upload it to your trade journal right away, while the entry, the level, and your reasoning are still vivid. Wait until the next morning and you’ll remember a cleaner story than the one that actually happened.
“If you take that loss, what do you do? You start journaling it. That’s what you do… you make sure you’ve taken screenshots. You upload those screenshots to your trade journal.”
Screenshot the bad trades on purpose, not just the losers that hit your stop. Capture the trades where you hurt yourself… the entry you instinctively knew you shouldn’t take. Those are your C-level and D-level trades, and the whole point of documenting them is to find them, name them, and remove them from your repertoire for good.
“Screenshots — bad trades. Where do you hurt yourself? Which trade are you instinctively knowing you shouldn’t take? What are those C-level and D-level trades? Let’s remove them from your repertoire.”
Then leave an extensive note. George does this on his own end-of-day charts so anyone can go back and read exactly what went wrong… “please go look at the end of the day chart. I left an extensive note on that loss” (Jul 16, 2025). A screenshot with no note is a photo. A screenshot with a note is a lesson. This habit lives right next to your End of Day Chart Review.
The 15-Minute Break and the Three-Point Journal
Here’s George’s exact recovery process, the one he calls the mark of a righteous trader. After a loss, you process the emotion, extract the lesson, journal it, reset, and come back to your trade plan with renewed discipline. Feel it first. Then work it.
“They process the loss, extract the lesson, journal it, reset their emotions, and return to their trade plan with renewed discipline.”
Now the drill you can run today. After your next losing trade, step away for a full fifteen minutes before you do anything else. No revenge trade. No staring at the chart. When you sit back down, journal three specific things:
- What the loss taught you. The honest read on why it went against you… wrong side of price action, wrong hours, wrong setup, or simply a good trade that lost.
- What you did right. Where you followed your plan. Maybe you sized correctly, honored your stop, or didn’t add to the loser. Wins hide inside losses.
- One specific way to improve. A single, concrete adjustment for next time. Not ten resolutions… one.
“After your next losing trade, take a 15-minute break before doing anything. Journal three things. What the loss taught you, what you did right in following your plan, one specific way to improve.”
Then close the journal and move forward. The break is the firewall between one loss and a spiral of revenge trades. Same discipline as learning to close your trading platform and walk away.
Study Your 10 Best and 10 Worst Trades
Journaling one loss at a time is daily maintenance. This is the deep audit. Pull down your full transaction history from your platform, sort it, and isolate your ten best trades and your ten worst. George ran this exercise on a full year of his own live account and called the results genuinely insightful.
“Last night what I did is I pulled down my Tradovate trades for my live account for last year and sorted for my 10 best trades and my 10 worst trades. And that was really insightful.”
Sit with the worst ten and ask the uncomfortable question about each… “what was I thinking there? Why did I do that?” Patterns surface fast. Same hour of day. Same emotional state. Same setup you keep forcing. George even suggests printing them out so you’re studying them on paper, away from the live chart.
| Step | What to do | What you’re hunting |
|---|---|---|
| Pull | Export your full trade history from your platform for the period. | The raw record… no memory, no story. |
| Sort | Rank by result. Isolate your 10 best and 10 worst. | The extremes, where lessons live. |
| Screenshot / print | Capture each trade’s chart. Study them off the live screen. | Repeating setups, hours, and mistakes. |
| Journal | Note what worked and what you’d cut for good. | Your A-trades to repeat, C and D trades to drop. |
This audit answers a question most traders never ask themselves plainly… where do I actually make my money, and where do I give it back? That’s the backbone of keeping a real trading journal in the first place.
Review Your Wins When You’re in a Slump
Reviewing losses is only half the practice. When the losses start stacking and confidence wobbles, George flips the tape. You pull up the journal and study your successes… where you trade well, where you don’t, and what your winning trades have in common.
“Honestly, that is one of the best things you can do when you’re in a little bit of a slump. You pull up your trade journal and you go back and you look at your success.”
The goal is a clear map of your own edge… “this is where I do really well. This is where I don’t do well” (May 25, 2026). Knowing that in specifics makes an enormous difference. A slump usually means you’ve drifted from the setups that pay you. Your own record points you back home.
George takes it a step further as a morning warm-up. Before the session, he replays past trades on the chart. He revisits the good ones for inspiration and deliberately torments himself with the bad ones, because the sting works as a positive catalyst for the discipline he needs that day.
“I will in essence torment myself by looking at my bad trades because I know this will act as a positive catalyst… I use these to warm up in the morning ahead of the trading day.”
Don’t Pay Tuition Twice
This is the whole reason review matters. The worst loss is the one where you already knew the rule and broke it anyway. George names that feeling exactly.
“Now I’m paying tuition to a lesson I knew.”
The pain of an old mistake doesn’t have to come around again if you genuinely learn it the first time… “the blues don’t have to last if you learn them from your past” (Feb 20, 2026). That’s the payoff of the whole review habit. You pay for the lesson once, log it, and stop rebuying it.
Review also earns you the right to be proud of a loss taken well. George journals his counter-trades even when they lose, because the review measures the execution as much as the result.
“I can also journal: yes, I countered. Yes, I took the loss like a professional trader. And I didn’t reenter. I closed my platform. I didn’t get stubborn and bullheaded.”
And when you can’t crack a trade on your own, get another set of eyes on it. George invites traders to post a losing trade for group analysis… “feel free to post it here and we’ll do an analysis for you, because that’s game film that we get to go back and review and critique” (Apr 7, 2023). You can even submit a failed setup anonymously for him to review personally. Losses reviewed alone teach you something. Losses reviewed in a community teach you faster. That’s part of why traders never trade alone.
“The blues don’t have to last if you learn them from your past.”
“Writing is a grounding experience. It is good for the soul. It will create a body of work outlining your path.”
Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
How do you review a losing trade the right way?
What are the three things to journal after a loss?
Why should I screenshot my bad trades and not just my winners?
How do I review my 10 best and 10 worst trades?
What should I do when I’m in a trading slump?
Is a losing trade always a mistake?
Field Dispatch · Free
Get the Sunday Library Lesson
One lesson from this library in your inbox every Sunday… George’s own words, with the receipts. Part of the free SITREP.
DISPATCHED SUNDAYS 11:00 CT · UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME
- ✓13 free lessons
- ✓Take the Trader Test… are you cut out for this?
- ✓Risk rules, the ES/MES contract, Technical Analysis 101
- ✓Know where to go long
- ✓Know where to go short
- ✓Your daily ES trade plan drawn on your TradingView chart
“That stop-loss that felt painful, it taught you risk management. The FOMO trade that failed, it refines your patience. Your worst trading days are actually your best training days.”
See These Lessons Traded Live
Free · Train With George
Ready to train, not just read?
Every lesson in this library came from live trading. These two doors are where the training starts — both free.
