The Canary in the Coal Mine
The failure signals that warn a move is ending… what each side fails to do tells you control is shifting before structure ever confirms it.
2022–2026
A failure signal is what one side of the market tries to do and can’t. Bulls fail to grab an obvious high. Bears fail to make a new low. A hot level gets tapped and nothing happens. In ES E-mini futures, these small failures are your earliest read on shifting control… they show up before any structure break confirms the turn. George calls the loudest of them the canary in the coal mine.
“I told the group is the canary in the coal mine that we did not take the RTH high and overnight high.”
This page gathers what George teaches about reading failure across hundreds of hours of live ES and MES micro futures sessions. The obvious high nobody grabbed. The new low the bears never made. The sluggish tap at a level that should have exploded. Each one is a piece of evidence about who really controls the tape.
Read What Each Side Fails to Do
Price action is a contest. One side pushes, the other answers. To read control, watch the thing a side couldn’t pull off. When the bears drive lower and the buyers refuse to hand over the RTH low, that failure is the tell. Strength lives in what the other side could not do.
“What couldn’t the bears do here? That once again signifies strength of the bulls. What couldn’t they do? They couldn’t take this RTH low. It couldn’t take that RTH low. Monster move up. Bulls, baby bulls.”
It cuts both ways. On October 14, 2025, George read the sellers as broadly in charge, then flagged the crack in their story… “The bears control in my opinion, but they didn’t grab this RTH low.” A side that owns the tape takes the obvious liquidity. When it skips that liquidity, someone else is wrangling control away from them. That is the whole game: who controls the market, read one failure at a time.
“What couldn’t the bears do here? That once again signifies strength of the bulls.”
The Canary: Failing to Grab an Obvious High
Here is the single most-repeated failure George watches for. Price ladders up all night, then stalls short of an obvious reference high… the London high, the overnight high, the RTH high. It should be easy to reach. It doesn’t reach. That miss is the canary in the coal mine.
“Failing to grab that London high, I said that is a warning flag. That is a red flag for sure. Doesn’t mean I need to get short.”
Notice the discipline in that quote. A red flag is a reason to pay attention, and only that. The failure to get the London high shows George “the weakness of the Bulls” (Feb 5, 2025), and it sharpens as more evidence stacks. That same day the read matured into a plan… failure to get the London high, then losing the opening, then losing VWAP, then breaking under the Strong Level. One canary invites the others. Together they point lower.
Could you act on the canary alone? Sometimes, small. On May 27, 2026 George framed it plainly… “if it is this canary in the coal mine failure to get the London high. That doesn’t mean go short yet, but could you take a speculative short? Sure.” Speculative means small. The signal earns a probe, never the farm.
“We didn’t get the overnight high. There was another previous IB high up here. We didn’t grab either of those. Is this some writing on the wall? I am waiting for us to take out the overnight low.”
See the pattern. Two obvious highs skipped, so George stops waiting for the upside and starts watching the overnight low for the real move. The failure reoriented the entire day.
Bears Can’t Create a Backside
This is the flip side, and it’s a named read George returns to again and again. A backside is the follow-through after a down move… the second leg lower that confirms sellers are in control. When the bulls have held for days and the bears drive a move but produce no backside, the shorts are trapped. That failure to extend usually spells a turnaround.
“When the bears try to get a move and they can’t create a backside, that usually spells trouble for shorts. That’s one reason I pulled my stop down to a 20 pointer.”
Read that last line. The signal changed his management, not just his opinion. No backside meant trouble for shorts, so he trailed his stop to lock a 20 pointer. Two days later he repeated the exact frame… “When the bears can’t create a backside, when the bulls control, that’s a problem.” (Jan 24, 2026). A problem for whoever is fighting the trend.
The same failure appears in its purest form as a market that simply won’t print a new low. When the bears cannot even reach lower to test a level, that inability is bullish on its own… “the fact that the bears can’t even get down there and test it to me is bullish” (Apr 8, 2026). Careful shorting that.
“Typically when you’re at these high timeframe trade locations and they can’t make a new low… after an amazing week of pulling price down to here, we made it. Couldn’t make a new low. We got a really nice explosion.”
That’s the payoff. A repeated failure to make a new low at a big high-time-frame location often precedes an explosion the other way. Same logic drives the short covering rally… trapped sellers who can’t get their move become fuel for the squeeze.
A Failure Is a Signal, Not a Green Light
Every quote so far carries the same warning. A failure tells you a move might be ending. It does not tell you to reverse and load up. George is relentless about this line. The canary means watch, get ready, stay light… it never means blindly flip.
“That’s me. I’m at three times in a failure to make a new low. It doesn’t mean to go long. I need to see laddering now. So, I’m watching for the reclaim of the opening in this Strong Level.”
Three failed new lows and still no long. He wants confirmation… laddering back up, a reclaim of the opening and the Strong Level. The failure builds the case. The reclaim closes it. That sequence keeps you out of the trap where a weak side keeps grinding long after it “should” have quit.
And a rally in progress never rules out a fresh low later. Stay guarded even inside a winner… “just because we are moving up now doesn’t mean we don’t make a new low today” (Jan 21, 2026). Same idea on the way down. A few small bounces are not a bottom. On September 5, 2025 George warned “the bulls still have not defended anything… we haven’t broken anything to the north and we haven’t had a first bounce yet. So, careful.” No defense, no trade. It’s the same discipline behind No Level, No Trade. You need real evidence. A hunch doesn’t count.
“It doesn’t mean to go long. I need to see laddering now.”
Hot Levels, Warning Shots, and Sluggish Taps
Failure has one more face… how a level reacts when price finally reaches it. When a side truly controls, its key levels run hot. Price either explodes off contact or never gets there at all. A slow, mushy tap at a level that should be electric is a failure signal all its own.
“Like these need to be hot levels for the bulls. It touches and goes, touches and goes, or it doesn’t even touch them at all. If the bulls are real, we may not even test this. And if we test this, it’ll be such a ladder back reaction with a vengeance that you go, Wo!”
Read the reaction. A hot level snaps back with a vengeance or gets skipped entirely because the strong side never needs it. When price instead crawls up to a level it “should” have ripped through, that sluggishness warns you. On May 31, 2026 George flagged exactly that… “It’s a little bit of a red flag that you can’t reclaim an overnight break level. Traditionally, when the bulls control in this scenario, it would have ripped through it. It didn’t. So that’s concerning.” Bulls in control rip through. Sluggishness is the crack in the story.
| What you see | What it fails to do | What it warns |
|---|---|---|
| No high grabbed | Ladders up, misses the obvious London / overnight / RTH high | Buyers are weak… canary for a move lower |
| No backside | Bears drive down but can’t extend or make a new low | Shorts trapped… turnaround or squeeze building |
| Sluggish tap | Crawls to a level instead of reacting hot | Controlling side isn’t real… fade the move |
| No reclaim | Can’t take back an overnight break level | Trend side is faltering… concerning |
| Every push sold | Each rally gets taken back in the RTH session | Sellers still own it… don’t fight the tape |
George also names the level itself. A key zone can be a warning shot… the spot where a side must respond or lose the tape. Watch whether they answer. On November 18, 2024 he mapped a break and asked the question live: “this was the updated Strong Level, this is where I thought it was a warning shot to bears and did they respond. I think they responded.” A year later, same read from the other direction: “this one was warning shot to bears… if they got beyond this warning shot to bears, hey, that’s a warning shot, guys. Be careful.” (Oct 18, 2025). Levels ask a question. Failure to answer is the signal.
The everyday version is simpler still. When every rally gets sold back, sellers still own the session… “every little push that London has had has been taken back in the RTH session… every pushup has been sold. When does that change?” (Feb 26, 2025). Until it changes, respect the side in control and keep countertrend attempts small, the way Touch and Go demands.
Every High Below the Range Is Suspect
Location decides how much to trust a high. While price trades under a broken high-time-frame range, treat every rally as guilty until proven innocent. It could be nothing more than a lower high before the market rolls back in.
“We are still under the high time frame range. So, every high I am very suspicious about… it could be nothing more than just a lower high and we come back in.”
George flags this before the trade, not after. On January 2, 2026 he told the room in the AM Briefing that the move might be nothing more than a lower high, which made a long there brutally hard positionally… “trying to go long in there is real difficult positionally.” Calling the failure in advance is what turns a signal into a plan.
The mirror image is just as useful. A failure to trade back down to a reference can be the bullish tell. When price won’t return to yesterday’s PAC or the RTH open, that reluctance shows strength… “the fact that it’s failing to get back to PAC is actually bullish” (Oct 1, 2025). A strong side can grab the liquidity “without having to get there” (Jan 28, 2025), front-running the level instead of tagging it. Whichever way it points, the read is the same: what price refuses to do tells you as much as what it does. That is why the ES leans long. The buyers keep failing to fully hand it back.
“It went back up and made one more tiny high. That is one of my favorite moves. It goes and makes one more tiny high.”
One of his favorite setups is the flip of a canary. Price fails to follow through on a short and grinds out one more tiny higher high. That failure to break down, followed by the small new high, is a clean tell the buyers are still there.
“So the point of this is are we all on the same train. That is really the biggest point.”
Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
What is a failure signal in price action trading?
What does “the canary in the coal mine” mean in trading?
What does it mean when the bears can’t create a backside?
If price fails to make a new high, should I go short?
How can I tell if a key level is strong or weak?
Why is every high suspect below a high time frame range?
Field Dispatch · Free
Get the Sunday Library Lesson
One lesson from this library in your inbox every Sunday… George’s own words, with the receipts. Part of the free SITREP.
DISPATCHED SUNDAYS 11:00 CT · UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME
- ✓13 free lessons
- ✓Take the Trader Test… are you cut out for this?
- ✓Risk rules, the ES/MES contract, Technical Analysis 101
- ✓Daily Live Stream
- ✓The Battle Plan
- ✓And more…
“That was further evidence of okay, this thing might have a move built in it.”
See These Lessons Traded Live
Free · Train With George
Ready to train, not just read?
Every lesson in this library came from live trading. These two doors are where the training starts — both free.
