The Bull Bear Scorecard
Tally the signals, count the check marks, and read which way the current runs… before you ever place a trade.
2022–2026
The Bull Bear Scorecard is a running tally. As you trade, you hand each observable signal a check mark for the bulls or a check mark for the bears… the opening, the initial balance break, the slope of VWAP, distance from VWAP, the halfbacks, the posture of the index instruments. Count them up. Whichever side collects more marks earns the benefit of the doubt in ES E-mini futures. No single check mark is a trade. The scorecard tells you which direction the current is heading.
“I want to talk about the Bull Bear Line… the Bull Bear Scorecard actually is what this is, and this is a very good thing to think about as you’re trading during the day.”
This page gathers everything George teaches about the scorecard across hundreds of hours of live ES and MES micro futures trading… the exact signals that earn a mark, how VWAP slope and distance vote, when the scorecard flashes a warning, and how the count becomes your directional bias for the day. It pairs closely with the Bull Bear Line and answers one question every futures day trader asks at the open: who is in control?
What the Scorecard Actually Is
Think of a card table. Every session deals a fresh hand, and the scorecard is how you count it. You watch the market build, and you keep a simple ledger of check marks… one column for the bulls, one for the bears. Rejection off the opening. Failure to grab the overnight high. Each observable event drops a mark in a column.
“That is definitely a check mark for the bears right there. Couldn’t grab the all-time high, which is the overnight high. Another check mark for the bears. That doesn’t mean go short, but if we’re keeping a little bit of a scorecard, that’s interesting, right?”
Read that last line twice. “That doesn’t mean go short.” The scorecard builds a read. One check mark for the bears tells you where the weight is leaning, and nothing more. George calls it an exercise you run on your own… “this is a great exercise you can do on your own when you’re trading” (Mar 25, 2025). Do it long enough and the market stops feeling like noise. It starts reading like a story with a direction.
When the count lands lopsided, the message is loud. “Everything was in favor of the bulls… this is telling you the current is heading north.” That is the payoff. A clean, one-sided tally that points the current for the whole session.
The Signals That Earn a Check Mark
What goes on the scorecard? George works through a fixed set of structural signals, top to bottom, and grades each one. Here is the ledger he runs live.
| Signal | What it measures | Marks the side that… |
|---|---|---|
| High time frame trend line | The dominant slope on the higher time frame. | owns the larger trend. |
| Overnight inventory | Where the overnight session left price relative to the range. | built position in its favor. |
| The opening | Reaction off the open… rejection or acceptance. | rejects price back toward it. |
| Initial balance break | Which side breaks the first-hour range. | breaks and holds the IB. |
| VWAP slope | Is VWAP tilting up or down? | price sits above a rising line, or below a falling one. |
| Halfbacks | Retrace back to the halfway point of a leg. | defends its halfback. |
| The indices | ES E-mini futures and NQ read together. | has both instruments aligned. |
Grade them one at a time. On June 9, 2026, George ran the full board out loud… “Let’s go look at our Bull Bear Scorecard. High time frame trend line, you got to give it to the bulls. Overnight inventory, give it to the bulls”. Mark after mark, the same side kept collecting. That is a scorecard doing its job.
The result is a verdict, delivered plainly. “At this moment, you have to put the benefit of the doubt to the bulls, but we are at the top of the range coming back in a little bit” (Jun 9, 2026). Notice the honesty. The bulls own the tally, and price is still stretched at the top of the range. The scorecard reads direction, and it respects location too.
VWAP: The Loudest Vote on the Card
VWAP carries more weight on the scorecard than any other single signal, and it votes in two ways. First the slope. Line up the instruments and check where they sit relative to a tilting VWAP. When ES, NQ, and the rest all trade above an upward-slanting line, that is a wall of check marks for one side.
“Above an upward slanting VWAP, above an upward slanting VWAP, above an upward slanting VWAP… at this time you have to say the bulls are probably in control.”
The repetition is the point. When every instrument tells the same story, the scorecard is not close. Just remember the qualifier George attached the same day… “we are in a 4-day balance, and until we get out of this 4-day balance I think range rules are more important”. A one-sided VWAP read still bows to a bigger balance. Direction and structure work the scorecard together.
The second VWAP vote is distance. How far has price stretched from the line? George keeps a reading on his chart that swells as the gap grows. Small distance means fair value. Large distance means an aggressive move is underway.
“This ES and NQ are large here, which denotes to us we are a large distance from our VWAP. We are in an aggressive move, is that indicator.”
He gives it a number. Beyond roughly 30 points from VWAP, the reading turns larger and the alarm goes off… “I find anything above 30 points I want to be alerted, and that’s why this will turn larger when it’s 30 points away” (Mar 29, 2025). Past that mark, the trade gets dangerous. “Once you lose that 30 points, it is really Watch Out Below in my humble opinion.” On a wild session he clocked price 58 points from VWAP, and called it exactly that: a wild day.
Distance also tells you where snaps happen. Price stretches at the outer VWAP bands, which is why George keeps them mounted on the chart… “ES made it down into the VWAP band, and that’s where price tends to get stretched” (Mar 27, 2026). And the line itself fights back. “Those VWAPs are responses. It’s a tough place to counter. It’s a very tough place to counter” (Apr 2, 2026). Score the slope for direction. Score the distance for danger. Respect VWAP as a response level either way.
Turning the Count Into an Arrow
A tally is only useful if it changes what you do. George converts the scorecard into a single mark on his chart… an arrow. Up means look for longs only. Down means shorts. Balance means either side is fair game. The arrow is the scorecard made simple, and it governs every entry.
“When I’m looking at price action and it’s telling me I want to be long… why go short?”
That is the whole discipline. You keep the arrow honest, and you trade in agreement with it. “I had it slightly up in this area… I would have still had my arrow slightly up. What does that mean? I’m looking for longs only” (Nov 7, 2022). The arrow moves when the evidence moves. “Then when we shot through the roof here, you gotta move your arrow to up.” A fresh check mark for the bulls, and the arrow follows.
This is how the Bull Bear Scorecard becomes your daily bias. Count the signals, set the arrow, take only the trades that agree with it. When the arrow points up, the bottom of a level is your spot… a page-perfect fit with range trading rules and the broader read of who controls the market.
When the Scorecard Flashes a Warning
Sometimes the count runs so lopsided that the scorecard does more than point a direction. It waves a flag. A pile of check marks stacked on one side, plus a big VWAP distance reading, means the move has real strength behind it. That is exactly when traders love to fade the extreme… and exactly when fading gets expensive.
“When you get the warning on the Bull Bear Scorecard here, that’s telling you, hey guys, there’s a lot of strength to this move. In other words, careful counter trading. You can do whatever you want. Just do it small. Don’t make things worse. Know where you’re wrong.”
Read the instruction inside the warning. He leaves the counter-trade on the table and shrinks it. Careful counter trading. Do it small. Know where you’re wrong. That is risk management wired straight into a direction read. When the scorecard screams strength, you size down and keep your stop tight… the same discipline covered in position sizing and stop loss placement. The scorecard tells you the current is strong. Respecting that keeps you from swimming into it full size.
“When you’re short in the bull’s control, you have to expect it.”
Keep Learning
Frequently Asked Questions
What is the Bull Bear Scorecard in trading?
How do you determine market direction in ES futures?
How does VWAP tell you if the market is bullish or bearish?
What does it mean when price is 30 points from VWAP?
Should you counter-trade a strong scorecard reading?
What is the arrow in George’s market direction system?
Field Dispatch · Free
Get the Sunday Library Lesson
One lesson from this library in your inbox every Sunday… George’s own words, with the receipts. Part of the free SITREP.
DISPATCHED SUNDAYS 11:00 CT · UNSUBSCRIBE ANYTIME
- ✓13 free lessons
- ✓Take the Trader Test… are you cut out for this?
- ✓Risk rules, the ES/MES contract, Technical Analysis 101
- ✓Daily Live Stream
- ✓The Battle Plan
- ✓And more…
“Everything was in favor of the bulls… this is telling you the current is heading north.”
See These Lessons Traded Live
Free · Train With George
Ready to train, not just read?
Every lesson in this library came from live trading. These two doors are where the training starts — both free.
